When to sell stocks: a decision laden with complexity, suspense, and often, a hefty dose of emotion. Knowing when to bid farewell to a part of your portfolio can feel like navigating a maze without a map, filled with questions of timing, profit, loss, and market shifts. 

The decision to let go is the crossroads where hope, fear, and pragmatism often collide, a moment fraught with the potential for exhilaration or regret. But what if we told you there’s a way to lift this mist of uncertainty? A method to bring order to the chaos and place the reins of control firmly in your hands?

That’s exactly what we intend on introducing you to in this complete guide to selling stocks – a deep dive designed to equip you with the insight, strategy, and confidence to decide when it’s time to part ways with a stock. And for those looking for an edge, we will introduce an innovative tool that can revolutionize your trading experience.

Trust us when we say: selling stocks doesn’t have to be a riddle wrapped in an enigma. With VectorVest, you never have to let human error, emotion, or guesswork interfere with your trading strategy. That being said, let’s start this conversation by assessing some of the challenges of figuring out when to sell your stocks.

Challenges of the Exit: Why Figuring Out When to Sell Stocks is So Tricky

You’ve done your research to find a swing trading stock and have picked a winner. You’ve watched its price rise, and you’re basking in the feeling of a decision well made. But now, the real test begins – when to sell your stocks

While buying a stock carries its fair share of thrill and risk, selling a stock ups the ante and introduces new complexities that can leave even the most seasoned investors scratching their heads.

The Psychological Difficulty of Selling: An Emotional Rollercoaster

The human mind is an intriguing landscape where logic and emotion often dance a complex tango. Nowhere is this dance more pronounced than in the decision to sell stocks. 

The fear of missing out on potential future gains battles with the desire to cash in on current profits. A part of you might hold onto the belief that your stock’s upward trajectory will continue indefinitely. This fear of regret can keep you hanging onto a stock even when your gut, and all signs, suggest it’s time to let go. It gets dangerous when the taste of having more – more returns, more money, more esteem – increases risk tolerance beyond your true comfort zone. You begin to build more confidence and make riskier investments. 

Simultaneously, there’s the fear of loss. Watching the price of a stock you own tumble can be gut-wrenching. The temptation to hold on, in hopes of a rebound, can be overwhelming. It’s a high-stakes game where holding on too long can lead to losses, and selling too soon can leave profits on the table. These decisions become sunk costs that cannot be refunded and make our future selves prisoner to our past.

This psychological conundrum makes the decision to sell stocks an emotional rollercoaster, one that requires nerves of steel and a well-defined strategy.

Logical Challenges: Tax Consequences and Reinvestment Dilemmas

Moving past the psychological barrier, the act of selling stocks ushers in practical concerns that demand attention. The foremost among these is the trading tax after you capture a profit. 

Profits from selling stocks are taxable, and understanding how these taxes work and affect your net returns is crucial. Timing your exit just right to optimize tax outcomes adds another layer of complexity to the process – just as taxes on options trading does.

Then, there’s the question of reinvesting the proceeds from your sale. It’s not enough to just sell a stock – you need to have a plan for what you’re going to do with the money you’ve just freed up. This requires constant stock analysis and research, trend analysis, and due diligence. It’s a continuous cycle, and the moment you sell a stock, you’re back at square one – scanning the market for the next opportunity.

Selling stocks isn’t merely the end of one journey – it’s the beginning of another. It’s the turning of a page where the excitement of profits meets the reality of challenges – a crossroad where the emotional, logical, and practical aspects of investing intertwine. 

Figuring out when to sell your stocks can indeed be tricky, but it’s not an unsolvable puzzle. Below, we’ll offer insights into the factors that influence when you should sell your stocks. Then, we’ll show you how VectorVest can simplify this for you and automate it – removing you from the process all but entirely!

When to Sell Stocks for Profit or Loss: Tips on Determining When to Close Your Position

At this point, we’re going to unpack the considerations that go into when you should close your position and move that capital to the next opportunity – whether you’re exiting with a profit or a loss. And, we’ll also offer tips on navigating this complex process. 

Timing Your Exit: Securing Profit and Mitigating Loss

Timing is everything in the stock market, and getting your exit strategy right can mean the difference between securing a profit and incurring a loss. It’s crucial to remember that the best time to decide when to sell a stock isn’t when it’s in free fall or soaring high – it’s when you buy it.

Setting a clear goal and defining your exit strategy upfront can help reduce emotional decision-making and protect your portfolio. For instance, a common strategy used by many investors is setting a target price or a target percentage return. If the stock hits this target, it’s time to sell.

On the flip side, you should also consider the downside. Determining a “stop-loss” level can limit your exposure to significant losses. If the stock falls to this predetermined price, you sell to prevent further losses. This strategy acts as a safety net and protects you from market volatility, automatically cutting losses for you should the time come. 

We’ll talk more about that later on. Let’s look at one of the most important factors of when to close out your position: market conditions.

The Role of Market Conditions

Market conditions play a significant role in your decision to sell. A booming market may encourage you to hold onto stocks longer in the hope of more significant returns, while a downturn may make you more risk-averse. 

However, you need to tread carefully. Succumbing to market hysteria can lead to poor decisions, such as selling in a panic during a downturn or holding onto stocks for too long in a bull market. This is something we talk about extensively in our separate conversation on stock market sentiment indicators.

Understanding broader market trends and economic indicators can provide essential context to your decision-making. For instance, during an economic downturn or recession, even well-performing stocks can suffer – as we talk about in our guide to navigating the stock market during recession.

All of this is to say that it’s crucial to separate the performance of your stock from overall market conditions to make an informed decision. Now, let’s assess the actual performance of your stock itself.

Stock Performance

The performance of the stock itself is, of course, a key consideration. If the stock’s fundamentals have changed significantly since your purchase, it might be time to reconsider your position. Declining sales, mounting debts, management shake-ups, or regulatory issues are just a few reasons to contemplate selling.

While a stock’s past performance doesn’t always predict its future, it’s sometimes all the information you have. No one can predict the future after all.  That’s why you should keep past performance in mind when evaluating the company’s future prospects, its position within the industry, and any upcoming events or announcements that could affect its price.  For this reason, VectorVest provides a stop price on every stock at every entry price.  This accounts for the stock’s past performance and volatility.  More volatile stocks get a little more cushion, while blue chip stocks have a bit of tighter stop price.  Sample this for yourself with our free stock analysis tool

Personal Financial Goals

Finally, and perhaps most importantly, your personal financial goals play a pivotal role in your decision to sell. Are you saving for a house down payment, trying to retire on dividends, earning supplemental income for upcoming bills, or saving for your children’s education? The timeline for when you need the money can greatly influence when you decide to sell a stock.

Remember, investing is personal. What works for one person may not work for another. Keep your financial goals front and center, and let them guide your decisions.

While these considerations can provide a guide, the decision of when to sell a stock is often complex and multi-faceted. It’s about balancing potential profit with acceptable risk while navigating the ever-changing landscape of market conditions. 

Now, before we get into actually executing the “exit” from your position, we want to offer some general advice on when to sell stocks for profit and when to sell stocks for loss

General Advice on When to Sell Stocks for Profit

  • Percentage Gains: It can be prudent to sell a portion of your stocks once you’ve reached a substantial profit margin, say 20-25%. This allows you to secure profits while still having skin in the game if the stock continues to rise. This is called “selling into strength”.
  • Target Achieved: Set a specific profit target – potentially 10-20% above your purchase price – and consider selling if the stock hits this mark.
  • Rapid Gains: If a stock’s price climbs rapidly within a short period, such as 40-50% in a few weeks, it may be overbought. This could signal an ideal time to take profits before a potential price correction.

General Advice on When to Sell Stocks at a Loss

A common rule of thumb is to cut losses at around 10% below your purchase price. This way, if a stock turns out to be a poor performer, you’re limiting the damage it can do to your portfolio.  With a 10% stop you limit your downside risk by 10% but this can also bounce you out of stocks that should really be given a little more breathing room.  VectorVest provides a stop price on every stock at varying entry prices.  This accounts for the stock’s past performance and volatility.  More volatile stocks have a larger stop, while more consistent  stocks have a tighter stop price.  Sample this for yourself with our free stock analysis tool

But, this is something investors really struggle with – as they maintain an emotional connection to the stock. That being said, let’s talk about how you can remove yourself from the process of exiting positions to eliminate these instances.

Never Wonder When to Sell Your Stocks for Profit or Loss Again: Introducing Stop Losses

One of the most effective ways to take control of your exit strategy and protect your investments is by using stop losses. 

Stop losses, if used correctly, can automate the selling process, ensuring that you’re not leaving your investments to the mercy of emotional decision-making or unpredictable market swings. They are a tool designed to help investors manage risk and secure profit, making them an essential part of your investment toolkit. 

Let’s pull the curtain back and examine how these can work in your investing strategy.

How Stop Losses and Take Profits Work

A stop loss is a predetermined price at which you will sell a stock if its value falls to that level. For example, if you bought a stock at $100 and set a stop loss at $90, your shares would be automatically sold when the price reaches $90, limiting your loss.

On the other hand, a take profit order is set at a particular price level above the current market price. When the stock reaches this price, the shares are sold, and the profit is secured. For instance, if you set a take profit order at $110 for the same stock purchased at $100, the trade will be executed when the price hits $110, ensuring you walk away with your anticipated profit.

You should be using both of these in your trading strategy to eliminate human error and emotion from getting in the way of your decision-making. We’ll elaborate on why we feel this way below…

Why These Belong in Your Strategy

Stop losses and take profits belong in your strategy because they add discipline to your investing process. They protect your portfolio from excessive losses, help lock in profits, and minimize the emotional factors that often lead to poor investment decisions. They also allow you to automate your strategy, saving you time and stress. 

Is There a Reason to Not Use Stop Losses?

While stop losses are generally a good idea, there are situations where they may not be suitable. For example, long-term investors with a high risk tolerance may choose not to use stop losses, as they can withstand temporary market dips and are more concerned with long-term growth. 

This is one of the many differences between strategies like dollar cost averaging vs timing the market and timing the market vs buy and hold. Additionally, if a stock is highly volatile, a stop loss could be triggered prematurely, leading to an unnecessary sale.  This is why we’re proponents of stops that are based on the stocks past performance. 

Types of Stop Prices and Strategies You Can Consider

Hopefully, you can see the value in implementing stop prices in your trading strategy. The question is, how do you actually go about setting them up? There are a few different strategies you can consider…

The Ratchet Stop

Like a climbing ratchet that only moves upward, the Ratchet Stop follows your stock’s price only in the upward direction. You set a stop price when you purchase a stock, and if the stock’s price rises, you raise the stop price accordingly. This way, you lock in most of the profits earned from the stock’s price increase.

However, keep in mind that this method has its risks. If your stock’s price dips and then quickly rebounds, your stock could be sold prematurely at the stop price, causing a missed opportunity for future gains. 

Also, frequent price fluctuations can lead to ‘whip-sawing’, where you sell a stock and then buy it back at a higher price, leading to decreased profits. While the Ratchet Stop reduces risk, it may not lead to the highest profit performance.

The Trailing Stop

The Trailing Stop is a slightly less conservative strategy where the stop price is allowed to fluctuate along with the stock’s price. With platforms like VectorVest that calculate new stop prices daily, this approach becomes easy to implement. It allows your stop price to lower with the stock’s price, decreasing turnover, commission costs, and the risk of whip-sawing.

However, there is an essential rule when using the Trailing Stop. Once your stock’s price rises above your purchase price, never let the stop price fall below the purchase price. After all, why risk a loss when you had a profit?

The Guidance System

For investors who find stop prices too mechanical, the Guidance System might be a suitable approach. Here, stop prices serve more as a guide, a signpost on when to consider selling, rather than a hard sell trigger.

This method works well if you’re an active investor who can devote time to the markets, allowing you to make well-informed decisions. However, for those who are busy or often traveling, this approach can leave you vulnerable to unexpected market downturns.

The Guidance System method might yield higher profits if you invest in safe, reliable stocks with strong growth rates. These stocks do not require frequent trading, thus potentially maximizing your returns over time.

Using Mental Stop Prices

Some investors prefer maintaining control over when a stock is sold, using stop prices as a mental marker rather than placing actual stop loss orders. This method is particularly beneficial for portfolios with several stocks.

For example, an investor with a ten-stock portfolio might set a mental 10% stop loss on each stock. This way, even if one stock falls by 10%, the total portfolio only suffers a 1% loss.

In a similar vein, money managers with portfolios of 20 or more stocks might use a 20% stop loss. This approach provides the stock more room to fall without significantly affecting the total portfolio. However, remember that mental stop prices require discipline and constant monitoring to be effective.

Automate Your Stop Losses With VectorVest!

Unsure of how to accurately implement the strategies discussed in this guide? Fret not, VectorVest has you covered! As the best stock analysis app and portfolio management system, we’re proud to offer an automated feature designed to streamline your stop loss process.

VectorVest delivers daily updates of Stop-Prices for every stock in the market, ensuring that you’re always in control and on top of your investment game. It also incorporates the principles of the Ratchet, Trailing, and Mental Stop-Prices, allowing you to customize your strategies to your preferences.

Better yet? Use dynamic stops through ProfitLockerPro. It connects directly to your brokerage account and analyzes the volatility of each stock you own. Then, it tells you when to sell a stock to lock in profits or cut losses. No emotional decisions, doubt, or regrets. Just consistently strong profits.

Learn more about what our stocks software can do for you today – either through a free stock analysis or by getting set up with a mobile stock advisory!

Wrapping Up Our Guide on When to Sell Stocks For Profit or Loss

And there we have it – a comprehensive guide to understanding when to sell stocks for profit or loss. From exploring various selling strategies like the Ratchet, Trailing, Guidance, and Mental Stop systems, to providing general advice on capturing profits and cutting losses, we’ve covered the landscape of this crucial aspect of investing.

You can learn more about swing trading for beginners in our blog, with detailed resources on topics like the best indicators for swing trading, the best stocks to swing trade, the best moving averages, swing trading options, position trading, and more.

Remember, every selling decision should be an informed one, driven by strategic considerations and not emotional reactions. And with tools like VectorVest at your disposal, managing these decisions becomes a lot easier. So, what are you waiting for? Get your account confirmed today and never question when to sell your stocks again.

What you should do next…

  1. Get our latest blogs delivered right to your inbox, subscribe to our newsletter.
  2. The market moves fast! Get our most current evaluation of this stock with our FREE stock analysis tool.
  3. Looking for stock picks? Not sure if now is the right time to buy/sell? For a limited time, enjoy the full benefits of a 30-day subscription to VectorVest for only $9.95 (usually up to $139/month) . Get access to our full list of screeners showcasing our top stock picks that tell you exactly what to buy, when to buy, and when to sell.